Andrey Liscovich was at house in downtown San Francisco when he noticed a tweet from the American politician Marco Rubio: “The #Russian invasion of #Ukraine is now underway.”
He felt sick. The 37-year-old Ukrainian had spent a lot of the earlier decade working removed from his native nation, together with as chief government officer of Uber Works, a subsidiary of the ride-booking group, earlier than creating his personal tech start-up. But Liscovich was born in Zaporizhzhia, on the border of the south-eastern Donbas area now struggling intense Russian bombardments.
“When I saw the news, and that [president Volodymyr] Zelenskyy was staying, I knew I had to go back to fight,” he remembers. So he boarded a aircraft to Poland and made his approach throughout Ukraine to Zaporizhzhia, planning to enlist. He wrote his will on the flight.
But when he arrived on the Zaporizhzhia conscription station, the recruiters instructed him that they didn’t need him to fireplace bullets however requested him as a substitute to make use of the tech abilities he had developed at Uber to assist army logistics. Liscovich obeyed: he tapped into his world networks to supply army uniforms and {hardware}, increase donations and assemble engineers to resolve issues corresponding to how one can detect Russian drones.
“Western partners trusted me to distribute stuff, give them actionable feedback and then adapt the product to Ukrainian conditions,” he explains throughout a visit again to San Francisco to harness assist from native software program engineers. He nonetheless spends a part of his time within the fragments of the Donbas area that stay below Ukrainian management, in order that he can observe his “customers” — Ukrainian troopers — in motion, with the intention to develop merchandise they’ll use.
“I like to say this is the world’s first open-source war,” says Oleg Rogynskyy, 35, one other Ukrainian who runs a Silicon Valley start-up. He can also be serving to the Ukrainian trigger and exchanging concepts with different computing engineers on social media websites, message teams corresponding to Signal, and GitHub, the platform the place coders change concepts.
This might sound a mere footnote within the relentless battle, because the Russians attempt to crush Ukrainian resistance. In the primary two months of the struggle, Ukraine’s nimbler forces usually outwitted and outfought the Russians. But extra lately the Russian military has been making grinding progress by way of relentless artillery barrage and aerial bombardment, taking increasingly territory within the Donbas. When Zelenskyy pleads for western assist, he asks for gadgets corresponding to long-range missile launchers, which the Ukrainian military desperately must repel Russia’s advance.
But the digital networks being organised by Liscovich and others are vitally vital. They assist to clarify why Ukraine has been in a position to withstand the Russian invasion for therefore lengthy; in addition they present how this battle may reshape different states’ method to struggle.
About the portraits
Ukraine-born photographer Dina Litovsky (b1979) developed her distant portraiture observe throughout the pandemic. She took the person portraits on this story from her house in New York, remotely controlling the themes’ smartphone cameras
The challenge at stake is how combatants organise themselves. The Russian army nonetheless seems to function in a hierarchical method — although it has potent cyber-hacking and misinformation capabilities. The Ukrainian military, in contrast, provides decentralised groups appreciable autonomy to make choices and innovate, and troopers talk straight with their friends in numerous models.
So, one method to body the struggle between Russia and Ukraine is as a contest between lateral networks and vertical hierarchies. Just as tiny Silicon Valley start-ups can disrupt legacy corporations through the use of agility, pace and bottom-up innovation, the Ukrainian military is making an attempt to compensate for its inferior dimension with an entrepreneurial spirit and engineers steeped in coding, hacking and video video games.
“What the Ukrainians have done with networks is striking, but that approach is completely antithetical to how someone like Putin operates,” Garry Kasparov, the previous chess champion and Russian dissident, instructed me. Or as former Google CEO Eric Schmidt observes: “Russia is playing a hierarchical war — top-down generals are planning the usual stuff. But Ukraine is playing a networked war.
“The real strategic question is: what is the limit of a networked war? We are going to find out.”
To perceive why lateral networks matter so deeply to the struggle in Ukraine, some historical past is required. In the times of the USSR, Ukraine’s economic system was centred on agriculture and heavy business. However, the nation at all times had loads of engineering expertise, because it had an enormous military-industrial advanced. When the Soviet Union broke up within the early Nineteen Nineties, many of those engineers embraced the fast-emerging web. “Russia has always had a large internal market, so Russian engineers were usually working for Russian companies,” says Rogynskyy. “But Ukraine’s market was very small, so Ukrainian engineers were always working for western companies, in English.”
Ukrainian universities rushed to serve this demand, making a homegrown ecosystem of IT expertise. And because the twenty first century wore on, a brand new era of techies emerged, usually nicely travelled, uncovered to western values and rich by Ukrainian requirements. “The engineers usually stayed in Ukraine instead of leaving, because the tax position was preferable — a $50,000 salary in Ukraine was like $300,000 in San Francisco,” says Rogynskyy.
Then the federal government obtained concerned. In the instant years after independence, Kyiv was cautious of the tech youngsters. But when Zelenskyy swept to energy in 2019, he introduced a few of them into authorities. One was Mykhailo Fedorov, an entrepreneur who was put in control of the digital ministry, on the age of 28. He beforehand ran a digital communications firm that helped Zelenskyy’s marketing campaign. He is keen about product improvement and obsessive about what Silicon Valley calls “UX” — consumer expertise analysis.
Fedorov recruited two dozen different homegrown tech consultants and set about making an attempt to digitise the Ukrainian authorities. They did this partly to make public companies cheaper and extra environment friendly. Fedorov tried, say, to conduct a census by counting SIM playing cards as a substitute of doing door-to-door surveys, and unveiled a plan at hand out free cellphones to all of the nation’s pensioners to allow them to make use of telemedicine. But the opposite motive he raced to embrace digitisation was to beat corruption, which has plagued post-Soviet Ukraine. “Corruption occurs when there are silos,” he says, talking by telephone from a authorities workplace in Kyiv. “We want to break them down.”
The most tangible results of this coverage is a smartphone app known as Diia — which means “state and me” in Ukrainian — which was launched in February 2020. This app can carry out cost companies, retailer driving licences and passports and distribute welfare. Since the struggle started, Fedorov’s crew have added a set of recent options that allow residents to report property broken by bombing and apply for compensation, maintain essential paperwork shut at hand in refugee camps and log the actions of Russian troops. The latter function worries some western observers because it blurs the road between civilians and combatants, but it surely has been extensively used. And, extra usually, some 18mn individuals — about 40 per cent of the inhabitants — are utilizing the app, in response to Fedorov.
When the Russians invaded, they tried to disable the digital hyperlinks that Fedorov had constructed. Many in Ukraine feared they’d succeed. “I hardly slept [before the invasion] because we had lots of cyber attacks on Diia and other portals,” Fedorov remembers. “The Russians knew how important the internet was for us and wanted to bring it down.”
The Russians launched cyber assaults and bodily missiles at knowledge servers and cell towers. The Ukrainians frantically fended off the cyber hacks, drawing on the expertise that they had gained from earlier assaults and assist from western allies. They have been helped by the truth that Diia is a smartphone app, distributed throughout hundreds of thousands of telephones, making it tougher to interrupt than a centralised database. “Everyone was impressed by how well the Ukrainians did [in defending themselves],” says Chris Krebs, former White House cyber safety head.
To make the system extra resilient, Fedorov’s crew additionally raced — below hearth — to take away knowledge servers from Kyiv, and uploaded as a lot knowledge as they might into the cloud to create backups. Then they seemed for tactics to maintain the web secure from missile strikes, which led them to Elon Musk.
Ukrainian engineers knew that Musk had developed so-called Starlink gadgets, cellular web terminals that hook up with a satellite tv for pc. Starlinks solely have a spread of 90 metres from the satellite tv for pc dish by way of cable or WiFi. But the fantastic thing about them is that they create a fragmented communications community: when they’re unfold throughout a area, they can’t be knocked out or jammed as simply as a single node, corresponding to a cell tower.
The Ukrainians knew Musk wished to show the powers of Starlink. So Fedorov despatched a public tweet to him, interesting for assist, and Ukrainian entrepreneurs privately used their contacts in enterprise capital to strengthen the plea. It labored: inside hours, Musk dispatched a number of hundred Starlink terminals to Poland, and Ukraine’s digital ministry then ferried them into hospitals, authorities buildings, railways terminals and significant infrastructure.
Roman Perimov was one Ukrainian engineer on this chain. Having studied nuclear engineering, he has labored over the previous twenty years as an IT challenge supervisor for giant western enterprises. In early 2022, simply earlier than the struggle began, he was about to maneuver to Philadelphia together with his household to run a worldwide programme for an enormous worldwide firm. “I can’t name them,” he says, talking to me by video throughout an in a single day army shift. Western corporations, he notes, are extra media-shy than the Ukrainian military.
When Russia invaded in February, Perimov moved his household to Poland earlier than he returned to Ukraine to enlist. He was dispatched to a motorised brigade, with orders to create a tech hub with a 30-strong crew. “When I came to the unit, there was almost nothing to do with IT — just two old computers and a half-dead printer,” in addition to unreliable web. But Perimov’s crew shortly assembled donations of computing {hardware} from engineering buddies, and his spouse drove throughout the Polish-Ukrainian border with among the all-important Starlink terminals in her automobile.
Once on-line, Perimov’s army crew began problem-solving, utilizing the identical sort of strategies that Silicon Valley engineers may use in a hackathon: rapid-fire experiments, with a mixture of on-line collaboration and competitors, performed on GitHub and Signal. “We pretty much work by ourselves, decide what to do and come up with solutions,” says Perimov.
One of the primary issues the engineers “hacked” was how one can shield the Starlink terminals from Russian assaults: they examined methods of hiding the terminals below camouflage blankets or piles of garbage. They mentioned how to make sure that the routers wouldn’t be detected by Russian planes or radar. Engineers brainstormed methods of making protecting instances for the terminals on a Facebook chatroom, and Rogynskyy and Liscovich did procurement checks with West Coast producers.
The engineers additionally hacked completely different communications programs, examined methods of flying drones and posted artillery targets for one another on shared coding platforms and specifically designed apps. “It’s networked,” observes Schmidt. “[One unit] posts the open-source co-ordinates of a tank, say, and then another group unknown to the first goes [to the co-ordinates] and deals with the tank.”
Now Perimov is engaged on a brand new challenge: making an attempt to incapacitate a small Russian drone known as Orlan, which can not simply be attacked with standard arms. “The problem with Orlan drones is that they can’t usually be hit by standard rifles [if they fly higher than 500m]. Neither can they 100 per cent be hit by Stinger-like missiles because they are so small and do not radiate enough heat to be detected by infrared,” he explains. “If you google for solutions, you won’t find any — I have looked and looked. So we are experimenting.” Rogynskyy and others have now linked Perimov with a San Francisco firm known as Dedrone which, he tells me, is donating a system for testing.
However, this iterative innovation course of goes nicely past drones. As quickly as western governments provide army {hardware}, the community of Ukrainian engineers hack it to make it simple for them to function. “What is critically needed now is modern software-enabled weapons like Himars [long-range missiles],” Perimov explains. “If we get it, we have more than enough specialists who can tackle and adopt it fast.”
As proof of this, he factors out a submit that lately appeared on the LinkedIn platform, promoting an engineer job for “a result-orientated and self-directed person” who needs to work with Himars. It claims to pay a wage of $7,600 and $10,000 a month. “Maybe it is a joke,” chuckles Perimov. “But maybe not — we [engineers] are all used to using LinkedIn anyway.”
In late June, when Liscovich was in San Francisco, I requested him how he was feeling concerning the struggle, and the destruction unfolding round his childhood house.
“Working in Silicon Valley taught me that when you are engaged in a start-up you cannot let yourself have emotional swings or it hurts your business,” he instructed me. “So I am doing the same now. I have a job to do.”
However, Liscovich is aware of the battle is getting more durable. He has created a so-called 501(c)(3) — an American tax-deductible enterprise — known as Ukraine Defense Fund for donations. Rogynskyy has accomplished the identical to boost cash to ship extra Starlinks. “But donations are slowing down,” says Liscovich. And though the US authorities is sending badly wanted shipments of army items, the programs for dispersing this are usually achingly sluggish. What makes issues worse is that Ukraine’s historical past of corruption means its authorities usually insists on intensive paperwork earlier than releasing any items. There are reviews of Starlinks piling up in warehouses in consequence.
The different massive issues are bodily fatigue, and scale. After months of gruelling battles, the Russians have made advances within the east of the nation, and up to now it’s not clear how a lot the Ukrainians can maintain them again. As army consultants level out, whereas networks are efficient for resistance campaigns, it’s much less clear whether or not they can be utilized for assault. “I am not complacent about what is going on — I do not underestimate the Russians,” says Liscovich, who spent years finding out in Russia; a few of his former buddies there “are probably working on the other side”.
However, what drives individuals corresponding to Liscovich, Rogynskyy, Perimov and numerous others is a passionate perception that entrepreneurial digital innovation is the important thing to successful each the struggle and peace. “I am confident we will win the war. Israel is the model,” says Perimov.
Liscovich is now again in his hometown of Zaporizhzhia, in search of everlasting places of work for the Ukraine Defense Fund. The city is “functioning normally on the surface”, he says, however enterprise exercise is “severely depressed” — not least as a result of the town is being hit by missiles. “You can get a room in a tower facing the central square of the city for just $150 a month.” Like any entrepreneur, he’s digging in for the long run. “This is the biggest start-up experiment of my life, of all our lives.”
Gillian Tett is chair of the FT editorial board and editor-at-large, US
FTWeekend Festival, London
Save the date for Saturday September 3 to hearken to Gillian Tett speak to Alex Karp, the chief government of Palantir. Gillian is one in every of over 100 authors, scientists, politicians, cooks, artists and writers at Kenwood House Gardens, London. Choose from 10 tents filled with concepts and inspiration, that includes the whole lot from debates to tastings. Book your move at ft.com/ftwf
Follow @ftweekend on Twitter to search out out about our newest tales first
